Are Protein Bars Healthy for You?

July 2011, Xtend-Life Expert

Summary

For many of us convenience snacking is a ‘normal’ part of our busy lives. So grabbing a ‘natural’ and ‘healthy’ protein bar seems a sensible way of providing sustained nourishment and energy. Right? Sadly not in most cases. Many of these ‘healthy’ bars are in fact loaded with preservatives, artificial colours, flavourings sweeteners, unhealthy fats and genetically modified ingredients, especially soy protein.

For many of us convenience snacking is a ‘normal’ part of our busy lives. So grabbing a ‘natural’ and ‘healthy’ protein bar seems a sensible way of providing sustained nourishment and energy.

Right? Sadly not in most cases.

Many of these ‘healthy’ bars are in fact loaded with preservatives, artificial colours, flavourings sweeteners, unhealthy fats and genetically modified ingredients, especially soy protein. You may even see these listed on the labels, but not realise their dangerous implications. Let’s look closer at some of the worst ‘offenders’:

1. Soy protein (unfermented)
Soy protein is one of the most common ingredients in protein bars because it enables manufacturers to claim "high protein" on the label, and is very cheap.

However, did you know that soy protein is usually extracted from GMO soy using hexane, a toxic petroleum solvent similar to gasoline, and that the soy protein processing forms a toxin, lysinolalanine, and a carcinogen, nitrosamines?

The processing also results in free glutamic acid or MSG, a potent neurotoxin. Extra amounts of MSG are added to many soy foods to mask soy's unpleasant taste.

Soy protein also contains:

  • High levels of phytic acid, which reduces assimilation of calcium, magnesium, copper, iron, and zinc, and is known to cause growth problems in children.
  • Trypsin inhibitors which interfere with protein digestion and may cause pancreatic disorders.
  • Phytoestrogens which disrupt endocrine function and maycause fertility problems and breast cancer.
  • High aluminum levels which are toxic to your nervous system and kidneys.

As a result, vitamin D and B12 levels are depleted and thyroid function hindered.

As you can see, unfermented soy is certainly not the ‘healthy’ ingredient claimed! Conversely, organic fermented soy is known for its health benefits. So, if a protein bar contains it, that’s good news.

2. Sugars
Many sugars and sweeteners in protein bars masquerade as healthy…even though they raise your blood sugar levels. The most widely used include:

2.1 High Fructose Corn Syrup
Almost all protein bars have this toxic sweetener which is so damaging to your health

To summarise, HFCS:

  • Is metabolized to fat (triglycerides and adipose tissue) in your body far more rapidly than any other sugar.
  • Disturbs your body’s appetite regulators, and creates insulin resistance causing you to gain weight (as well as diabetes and cardiovascular diseases)
  • Depletes vitamins and minerals

Avoid it!

2.2 Agave nectar
Agave nectar is labelled as a ‘natural’ sweetener by the FDA. This is very misleading because agave nectar is a highly processed very concentrated form of fructose, containing as much as 90% fructose – way more than HFCS’s 55% level. As concentrated fructose it’s metabolized directly by the liver and is linked to the same diseases as HFCS.

2.3. Evaporated cane juice
Although this sounds like a whole food, it is in fact a sugar with the same dangers as sugar. The advantage is that contrary to white sugar, evaporated cane juice should be processed so that vitamins, such as riboflavin and vitamin B, as well as amino acids and fibre are largely retained. \

This is more likely to happen if you chose an organic form. This site asks the good question: ‘is it really more healthy?’

2.4. Brown rice syrup
Like evaporated cane sugar, brown rice syrup has a ‘healthier’ sound. But beware!

IF you can find organic raw brown rice syrup you have a winner because it is fermented using active enzymes. These help to break down the complex carbohydrates to soluble carbohydrates, maltose and some glucose.

But not many manufacturers go to the considerable effort and expense of producing such a product. Rather they focus on commercial brown rice syrup which is produced more cheaply using GM enzymes and the potent neurotoxin MSG.

3. Fats
Most protein bars contain polyunsaturated fats or common vegetable oils such as corn, soy, safflower, sunflower and canola. These oils are highly susceptible to heat damage which destroys the antioxidants, oxidizing them. Oxidized oils cause far more damage than trans fats.

Corn, soy, and safflower oil contribute to the unhealthy overabundance of omega-6 fats in your diet, and the imbalance of the omega-6 to omega-3 ratio, and resulting ill health.

4. MSG
As mentioned, MSG is an excitatory toxin with disturbing side effects.

Most manufacturers are aware of this, yet they disguise the product by using other terms. See if you recognise them, and if so, avoid them! Barley malt, rice syrup, gelatine, corn syrup and corn syrup solids (unless stated as MSG-free,) carageenan, xanthin gum, citric acid (when processed from corn), malt extract, brown rice syrup, calcium caseinate, cornstarch, modified food starch, maltodextrin, isolates.

Now you know what to avoid in your protein bar, what makes a genuinely healthy bar?

Criteria for a Healthy Protein Bar
Look primarily for the right balance of nutrients. Most experts agree that the right ratio of macro nutrients is:

  • 19-25% protein (18-20 grams per bar)
  • Less than 5 grams of TOTAL healthy fats - lipolic acid, CLA (conjugated linoleic acid ) and MCTs
  • Less than 4 grams of Total carbs (check if the bar serves 1 or 2 - some unscrupulous bar makers indicate fewer carbs and fat on the label by turning their single bar into 2 servings.)
  • Less than 4 grams of unrefined organic sugar
  • 5 grams + of fibre

There is considerable debate about the best form of protein in a protein bar. This ranges from organic nuts, seeds, brown rice, hemp, yellow peas to whey protein.

Some argue that whey protein containing IGF-1 (or "Insulin Growth Factor-1"), leads to the proliferation of cancerous cells.

Others claim that whey protein is the best form especially when it is:

  • a concentrate, not isolate which is stripped from natural cofactors and hard to assimilate
  • from grass fed, hormone free cows resulting in whey which has a good amino acid and immuno-supportive nutrient profile, and is rich in healthy fats – lipolic acid and CLA.
  • Cold (not heat) processed to protect the nutrients in their natural state.

Ultimately, your taste buds will decide! But if you can combine that decision with the above guidelines, hopefully you can make an informed choice about your next truly ‘healthy’ protein bar!

10 Comments

  • “Thanks for your comments Mike and Dominique Yes the aim of the post is to provide Guidelines so you know what to look (out) for. Normally we are reluctant to give recommendations for products we don’t make ourselves as we can’t guarantee them. That’s why I didn’t name brands. However, I munch through a fair few delicious protein bars myself, so I understand. That’s easier said than done. because living on a small Caribbean island I must import them and incur double the cost. So they need to be pretty good for me to bother! So how about this……. On the basis that this is a personal recommendation of bars that taste great to me and that meet most of the above guidelines, BUT NOT a Guarantee of anything, I recommend the following: http://theprobar.com/products/ http://www.thegoodonyabar.com/ http://shop.bokusuperfood.com/detail_BOKUBAR__25.html http://www.livingfuel.com/CocoChia-Snack-Fuel-Bars.aspx  + http://www.livingfuel.com/Double-Chocolate-Bar.aspx http://www.boundlessnutrition.com/?page_id=450 That should be enough to keep you going! Caramia”

    Xtend-Life Expert - July 08 2011

  • “Thank you for your interest and use of our supplements Abito. Gosh, you have asked a BIG question! This is a complex area which defies a simple answer given that I don’t know your specific needs, aims and health condition. For example, a casual ‘gymner’ will have very different physical and nutritional needs to a serious body builder or weight trainer. My main recommendation is for you to learn from a reputable fitness and nutritional trainer. There are many, most poor! The best two whose advice I have sought are Tom Venuto http://www.burnthefatblog.com/category/food-nutrition and Mike Geary http://www.truthaboutabs.com/ Regarding the whey protein you quote, this looks like one of he better ones with a very high protein and low sugar content. Though the sugar, in the form of artificial sweeteners is a let down. Personally I am not into heavy weight training. But I am a fitness enthusiast, so in addition to a reasonably healthy diet, I supplement with the following protein / sources: Pure Power Protein  http://proteinpowder.mercola.com/pure-protein.html Protein Plus Superfood http://www.askdrgarland.com/shop/protein-plus.htm Sunwarrior protein http://www.sunwarrior.com/products/sunwarrior-protein I hope this helps Abito Caramia”

    Xtend-Life Expert - July 12 2011

  • “I don’t think one is made meeting these guidelines, if so i’d like to get the brand name.”

    Mike - July 08 2011

  • “Hello Alexandru In its natural form (soybeans) it is a good source of complete protein and very rich in minerals. Textured vegetable protein (TCP) however is a highly processed form of soybean, so I would be cautious. During the manufacturing process it is placed in a large aluminum tank and it does appear that this results in aluminum leaching into the finished product. I believe that aluminum cannot be easily cheated from the body but there are some supplements which help to reduce aluminium toxicitysuch as: - Magnesum citramate. Magnesium reduces brain levels of mercury and the citramate, a combination of citrate and malate, has been shown to significantly stimulate elimination of aluminum from the body. - Ascorbate (as magnesium or calcium ascorbate). A study found ascorbate to be a very effective chelator of aluminum, especially when the aluminum was bound to brain cell DNA. Taking higher doses of ascorbate with the magnesium citramate increased the removal of aluminum even more. - Malate. Malate was shown to be one of the more effective aluminum chelators for the brain. - Pyruvate (as calcium pyruvate). Pyruvate has been shown to effectively prevent aluminum absorption. - Flavonoids. Eat a lot of fresh vegetables. Supplements containing flavonoids, such as quercetin and hesperidin, also prevent aluminum absorption. Chlorella helps remove mercury and lead and may remove aluminum. Our Total Balance range also helps the natural detoxification process. Hope this helps Caramia”

    Xtend-Life Expert - July 15 2011

  • “Hi Lightwaves Thanks for your comment about Larabar. I have not tried it so I can’t give a personal view sorry. A quick look at their site information suggests that the bar has the essentials. But it really doesn’t give me enough information to be clear. I’m glad it works for you. Caramia ”

    Xtend-Life Expert - July 08 2011

  • “Dear Warren, What about textured vegetable protein (from soy) does it contain aluminum ? What can be done to chelate the existing aluminum from the body? Thank you.”

    Alexandru Lapugean - July 15 2011

  • “I’ll have an occasional Larabar that seems to be a fairly healthy snack during outdoor activities.  While not exactly a protein bar, it’s great when coupled with a trail mix.  Besides sugar, their label doesn’t have any of the aforementioned ingredients.”

    lightwaves - July 08 2011

  • “Hello Caramia, These are some impressively rigorous guidelines! I’m glad you provided some examples of the types of protein bars that meet your specifications. Though it doesn’t claim to be a protein bar, I’ve long favored Larabar, because it uses minimal ingredients that are essentially nuts and dried fruits (often dates) molded together. They are high in sugar because of the dried fruit, but there are no added sugars, they only come from the dates, dried cherries, etc. Just my two cents— thanks! Michael”

    Michael - October 18 2011

  • “Thanks Caramia for the honest comments.. Those links are very informative. The protein supplement from mercola looks good but they dont have free shipping. The sunflower I think is not for muscle building. Rgds, Abito”

    Abito - July 14 2011

  • “I agree with Mike. I’m so glad you are debunking the myth of "healthy" snack bars, but as there are none that meet the criteria that I know…would you be generous and give your readers a brand name…if there is any?”

    Dominique - July 08 2011

Leave a Comment

Topics you might be interested in


What Every Good Skincare Needs To Have

July 2018 by, Xtend-Life Expert

Antioxidants, peptides, Omega fatty acids… If you’re not an expert in skincare ingredients, or science, figuring out the best products to use on your skin can be confusing to say...

Read More